Westboro Baptist Church | The First Amendment challenges

Friday, January 3rd, 2014 By

U.S. Supreme Court building

The U.S. Supreme Court is set to decide if the hate speech of Westboro Baptist Church is protected. Image from Flickr.

After several appeals, the Supreme Court has agreed to take on the free speech questions raised by the Westboro Baptist Church. An extreme church known for protests against homosexuality at funerals, colleges and public buildings, the Westboro Baptist Church has faced a wide range of legal challenges. The case the Supreme Court will be taking on involves Albert Snyder, the father of a U.S. Marine killed in the line of duty. Originally, Albert Snyder was awarded $8 million in a judgment against the Westboro Baptist Church – an amount the church may not be able to get with even the cheapest personal loans. The main question under debate is if the extreme hate speech practiced by the Westboro Baptist Church falls under protection of the First Amendment.

The history of Westboro Baptist Church

The Westboro Baptist Church has been in existence since 1955. The Westboro Baptist Church claims affiliation with Primitive Baptist and Calvinist principles, but it is not affiliated with any Baptist church and most Primitive Baptists reject the Westboro Baptist Church. Based in Topeka, the Westboro Baptist Church pickets funerals, gay pride events, pop concerts, football games and statehouses. The Westboro Baptist Church pickets these events to spread their anti-homosexuality, anti-Jewish, anti-other-religions message. The leaders of the Westboro Baptist Church and other church members have been specifically banned from entering the United Kingdom because of their “unacceptable behaviour by inciting hatred.”

The legal challenges of the Westboro Baptist Church

Westboro Baptist Church and its members have encountered numerous legal challenges. Westboro Baptist Church has won several free-speech lawsuits against several cities and states. During WBC protests, members have been convicted of trespassing, disorderly conduct, failure to obey police and contributing to the delinquency of a minor. The Supreme Court has previously rejected cases challenging Westboro Baptist Church, allowing lower court rulings to stand.

Albert Snyder’s lawsuit against Westboro Baptist Church

In 2006, Albert Snyder sued the Westboro Baptist Church leaders for their protest actions at his son’s funeral. The lawsuit said the Westboro Baptist Church violated the Snyder family’s right to privacy, as well as defamation. In the original lawsuit, Snyder was awarded $8 million in punitive damages. On appeal, the district judge upheld the ruling against Westboro Baptist Church, but reduced the payday loans award for Snyder to $2.1 million. On federal appeal, the case was overturned and Albert Snyder was ordered to pay the legal fees Westboro Baptist Church had incurred during the lawsuit. In March of 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear Albert Snyder’s lawsuit.

Limitations on constitutional free speech

The basic argument in the Westboro Baptist Church supreme court lawsuit is whether there are limitations on Constitutionally-protected free speech. In Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire, the Supreme Court ruled that free speech does not protect “obscene utterances” and “certain personal slurs.” The lawsuit also considers the possibility that the free speech expression of the Westboro Baptist Church may have violated the Snyder family’s constitutionally protected right to freedom of religion – to hold and attend their son’s funeral. When two constitutionally protected rights come into conflict, the Supreme Court is asked to determine where the line between the two should be drawn.

Christian Science Monitor
Balitmore Sun

Previous Article

« Reverse Mortgages 101 | Reverse mortgages and how they work

Reverse mortgages are a way of selling your home back to the bank and getting the equity out of it -- but the details can be confusing. Bank owned
Next Article

National Boss’s Day | Celebrating without a brown nose »

Boss's Day is celebrated in six countries, but this Oct. 16 holiday can cause headaches in the office. Learn to navigate this day carefully. Best Boss

Other recent posts by bryanh

Bad Credit Loans Online: Installment loans for poor credit

Need a loan but have bad or poor credit? Bad credit loans online, like installment loans for poor credit, are available right here. CLICK >>

Advanced Borrowing Method: Easy no faxing payday loans online

You can get easy no faxing payday loans without having to go through the traditional hassles of getting even bad credit loans online. Apply!
Easy no faxing payday loans are available online

Can Short Term Loans Provide in Times of Uncertainty?

Discover how short term loans can be used to get you through emergencies. CLICK HERE for the real story.
In uncertainty, sometimes what we need is something like short term loans to hit us on the nose. (Photo: flickr.com)