Jared Loughner shooting puts Arizona gun laws in the crosshairs

Thursday, June 6th, 2013 By

Man displaying a holstered, concealed weapon in Gold Point, Nevada.

Arizona's position on concealed carry is highly controversial. (Photo Credit: CC BY/Mark Holloway/Flickr)

The recent tragedy in Tucson, Ariz., in which Jared Lee Loughner shot Rep. Gabrielle Giffords and 19 others – killing six – has added fuel to the fire for critics of the Arizona gun law. Specifically, critics point to Gov. Jan Brewer’s signing of Arizona Senate Bill 1108, which eliminated the need for a concealed carry permit. While some believe that Arizona’s current gun laws are appropriate, others think the concealed carry loophole makes the law too lax – and dangerous.

Arizona gun law and the wild west

The Glock-19 Jared Lee Loughner reportedly used for the Arizona shooting is a perfect example of Arizona’s concealed carry system at work. Arizona gun owners can carry their guns in vehicles, in restaurants and other public places. Critics argue that in the case of individuals like Jared Lee Loughner, the practice of concealed carry without a permit places weapons into the hands of the mentally unstable.

Gun control activists believe that only tighter federal controls via tougher background checks and bans on assault weapons can protect people from gun violence. Pima County Sheriff Clarence Dupnik, who is involved in the Jared Lee Loughner investigation, also believes that the concealed carry law contributed to the shooting of Gabrielle Giffords and others. Dupnik believes that if Arizona wants to be viewed as the wild west, the state is well on its way.

“We’re the ‘Tombstone’ of the United States of America,” Dupnik told the Los Angeles Times.

Are current background checks effective?

Gun rights supporters – the NRA included – point out that the National Instant Criminal Background Check System already includes criminal and mental health records. Yet Jared Lee Loughner’s run-ins with Pima Community College campus police would not have shown up in the background check, because mental health clearance – the condition of his potential return to school – was never obtained.

The right to defend oneself, politely

The Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution grants individuals the right to bear arms. The debate over the effectiveness of background checks will continue to rage on, and the tragedy in Tucson may play a role in change — that is, if the NRA doesn’t convince Washington to politely leave things as they are. As science fiction author Robert A. Heinlein once wrote, “An armed society is a polite society.”

Sources

Los Angeles Times

Talking Points Memo

Concealed carry in places of business

Previous Article

« Forever Stamps good regardless of future postage rate increases

Buy Forever Stamps now and never deal with needing those annoying 1- or 2-cent stamps again when postage rates inevitably increase ... no more postage increases
Next Article

Payday Loans: Going Where the Need is Greatest »

In a recent Federal Reserve study, Robin Prager discovered that the connection between credit-challenged areas and payday loan stores is very real. Payday Loans have the green light when it comes to going where the financial need is greatest. Access to conventional credit plays a large role. (Photo: flickr.com)

Leave a Reply

Other recent posts by Steve Tarlow

A Gallon of Scorpion Venom Will Kill Your Budget

Everything is expensive these days. Focusing on debt relief is tough when so many liquids we use are budget-busting by the gallon.
"Yessss! Thissss will cost them!"

Racial discrimination evident in continued bank redlining

Redlining still hasn't disappeared from minority banking, reports USA Today. Minorities are still shut out of many bank loans and mortgages.
A white piggy bank, shaped like a grenade.

Avoid the top 10 budget mistakes

When it comes to making a budget, you can't afford not to do it. These top 10 budget mistakes are easily avoidable, so listen up.